“I’m honestly surprised af so many people recognized my dress from hubby’s anniversary post!” Pike wrote on Instagram
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():focal(749x0:751x2):format(webp)/Amber-love-is-blind-111523-1-ed7316bfbac04ac89c0db44f920e3056.jpg)
Amber Pike rewore the dress from “Love is Blind” season 1 reveal. Photo:
Amber Pike/Instagram
Amber Pike is “shook” that some people know her closet so well!
On Monday, the Love Is Blind alum, 31, and her husband Matt Barnett, 33, celebrated their fifth wedding anniversary, but Pike pulled a dress from the archives that fans seemed to recognize.
During the couple’s celebration, they shared snapshots of their celebratory dinner, where Pike is seen wearing a seafoam dress alongside Barnett. The dress includes a ruching effect at the center of the bodice, a deep V-neck, thin straps and a deep slit in the center of the dress. She styled the look with a pair of nude strappy heels.
After Pike shared her look, she followed up with another Instagram post confirming to followers and comments that the dress was the same ensemble she wore when first met her husband.
The couple met on season 1 of the Netflix reality show and saw one another for the first time while Pike wore the ruched dress.
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():focal(381x0:383x2):format(webp)/Amber-love-is-blind-111523-3-93535111c7c14bb78771c5213e063b52.jpg)
Amber Pike shows off “Love is Blind” dress for fifth wedding anniversary.
Amber Pike/Instagram
She began her post by sharing her reaction to everyone’s accurate assumptions. “Current mood: SHOOK,” she wrote.
“I’m honestly surprised af so many people recognized my dress from hubby’s anniversary post! If it isn’t already obvious, yes I was wearing the exact same dress from when Matt and I saw each other for the first time…”
Pike continued, joking, “It fits a lil differently than it did 5 years and 30lbs ago but I think I can still make it work ?. “
Pike teased that she would bring the dress out of her closet every few years. “As a matter of fact, I’m planning on having this dress make an appearance every five years for as long as my size and the dress hold up, so she’ll be seeing you guys again in 2028 ?,” she wrote.
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():focal(381x0:383x2):format(webp)/Amber-love-is-blind-111523-2-479ace4f4db14d568502d24da7b77a42.jpg)
Matt Barnett and Amber Pike celebrate fifth wedding anniversary.
Matt Barnett/Instagram
‘Love Is Blind’ : 5 Behind-the-Scenes Secrets from Show Creator Chris Coelen (Exclusive)
Ahead of her confession, Pike and Barnett shared celebratory Instagram posts for their five-year anniversary. The post included a video of the couple walking hand in hand and kissing each other on the cheek.
“I love you more today than yesterday, yesterday you got on my nerves,” quipped Pike at the start of the caption.”5 years later and somehow I really do love you more today than the day we said ‘I do’. Don’t get me wrong, every day hasn’t been perfect and Lord knows there is plenty that we have gotten wrong over the years,” wrote Pike. “But the most important thing that I’m so thankful that we’ve gotten right is how much we are willing to work for each other to keep growing together.”
Love Is Blind’s Amber and Barnett Open Up About Their Marriage: ‘We Still Are Pretty Gross’
Never miss a story — sign up for PEOPLE’s free daily newsletter to stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer, from juicy celebrity news to compelling human interest stories.
In addition to Pike and Barnett, season 1 couple Cameron Hamilton and Lauren Speed Hamilton will also be celebrating their fifth anniversary on Nov. 16.
